12.09.2010

Product Review: Hi Vis Safety Parka

I've been in the market for a waterproof cycling rain jacket for quite a while now. It's been a tough search, but I finally settled on a VEA Safety Parka from RAF. Although it's not a cycling-specific jacket, Chris bought one and convinced me to give it a shot. Every jacket I've come across is missing at least one or two key features, this one seems to be my best bet.


My ideal cycling rain jacket would be/have (in no particular order):
  • Waterproof
  • Windproof
  • Breathable 
  • Highly-Visible (safety green, safety orange, or yellow)
  • Reflective piping
  • Hooded
  • Zip front
  • Durable
  • Lightweight
  • Economical
  • Compact
  • Good Fit
  • Exterior Pockets
  • 4-Season
  • Machine Washable
I know that this list is wishful thinking, however, identifying my main desired features has helped focus my search and provide a detailed review (I couldn't find any others out there).

So how does this VEA Safety Parka stack up?
  • Waterproof - Yes. I was surprised to find so many rain-type jackets on the market that are only "water resistant." The hood is detachable with button snaps, but well below the collar. Should not be a problem unless you're laying in a puddle.
  • Windproof - No / Kinda. Very wind resistant. Monday was the windiest day I've ridden in recent memory. The wind blew me around a bit, but I didn't feel any noticeable penetration with only a jersey underneath. Unfortunately there is no elastic or drawstring at the waist, meaning that headwinds go up the jacket when pedaling.
  • Breathable - Yes. The lining is polyester mesh and seems to take moisture off the body quickly on a cold day. Unfortunately, no armpit vents. 
  • Highly-Visible- Yes. This jacket is ANSI Class III compliant and is intended for law enforcement & safety applications.
  • Reflective piping - Yes. 3M Scotchlite reflective piping on upper chest & back, lower chest & back, over shoulders, and upper & lower arms. I happened to see Chris ride by an intersection yesterday evening while wearing his jacket, and this stood out very well in headlights.
  • Hooded - Yes. Drawstring hood stows and is detachable with buttons. It fits 2/3 over my helmet and will stay with drawstrings cinched, but definitely restricts head motion.
  • Zip front - Yes. Zipper & buttons. Unfortunately there are jackets out there only with buttons making them much less waterproof and a huge pain for quick temperature regulation while on a bike.
  • Durable - Yes. Quality construction, fabric, and double sewn seams.
  • Lightweight - Almost. The long cut of the jacket and heavier quality fabric prevents it from being light. Certainly not heavy.
  • Economical - Yes. At $46 + $10 shipping from the above retailer, an unbeatable price for its features.
  • Compactable - Mostly. I can roll my medium-sized jacket into a 12" wide & 4" diameter roll.
  • Good Fit - Eh. The fabric is a little stiff and the jacket is cut long and is loose in anticipation of layers of fleece underneath. Does not come in a small. I am a 36S and a medium looks large on me. The wrists are adjustable. The neck is too tight to ride zipped-up with the hood stowed away. With hood out the neck is fine.
  • Exterior Pockets - Yes. Two small button-pockets in the front at the waist, and one velcro cell-phone pocket at the left breast. I cram my keys in the cell phone pocket. I wish the bottom pockets were larger and used velcro for quick access and closing.
  • 4-Season - No. I will not be wearing this in the summer. However,  it is a good 3 season jacket. You can also purchase a fleece liner that zips in for winter.
  • Machine Washable - Yes. Machine wash cold with mild detergent. Tumble dry low. 

OVERALL: Certainly doesn't get any cool points for fashion, but will keep me dryer and help other road users avoid killing me. Two thumbs up.

    3 comments:

    1. Excellent review! Thanks for the tip.

      ReplyDelete
    2. I would also like to point out that for the "larger" cyclists, this is the probably the only reflective rain gear you will find that you can wear a fleece under.

      ReplyDelete